UHM: New Guidelines Make Aarogya Setu Mandatory For All-Aarogya Setu 2020

The new guidelines issued by the Union Home Ministry has stated that contract tracing app Aarogya Setu must be installed by all individuals residing within containment zones.


However, the national directives in the annexure to the order also states that all public and private sector employees will have to install the app, thereby expanding the mandated areas beyond the containment zones.
According to the latest directions, "the most sensitive areas of the country, from the spread of COVID-19 point of view, and falling within the Red and Orange Zones, are designated as Containment Zones."
This essentially means that containment zones will comprise 414 out of the country's 733 districts.
The Union Health Ministry, in a letter, identified 130 districts as red zones and 284 as orange zones.
 The new guidelines issued by the Union Home Ministry has stated that contract tracing app Aarogya Setu must be installed by all individuals residing within containment zones.Guidelines issues by Union Home Ministry on 100% coverage of Aarogya Setu in containment zones.
While the guidelines state that "100% coverage of Aarogya Setu app among the residents of the Containment Zone" shall be "ensured", the 'National Directives for COVID-19 Management' indicates that those in green zones will also have to install the application.
According to point 15 of the National Directives, issues along with the lockdown extension order states "use of Aarogya Setu app shall be made mandatory for all employees, both private and public."
While the point also says that organisations must ensure "100% coverage of all employees", it does not specify this as pertaining to any particular zone.
 The new guidelines issued by the Union Home Ministry has stated that contract tracing app Aarogya Setu must be installed by all individuals residing within containment zones.National Directives for COVID-19 Management
Additionally, containment zones would have intensified surveillance protocols, with contact tracing, house to house surveillance, home and institutional quarantining of persons based on their risk assessment, and clinical management.
Launched on 2 April, Aarogya Setu, developed by the Government of India, is a contact tracing tool. It is meant to help determine if you have come in contact with someone "who could have tested COVID-19 positive."
The app has come under severe criticism for privacy and surveillance concerns as well as the lack of audit and transparency.
Can Aarogya Setu Be Made Mandatory?
Th Home Ministry's latest guidelines mean the directions to make it mandatory for those people in the Constrained Containment Zones will likely be through orders by District Magistrates under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
This would also provide the means for enforcement. Failure to download and install the app would become punishable under Section 188 of the IPC (disobedience of an order by a public servant) or even, Section 51 of the Disaster Management Act (disobedience of an order by an official relating to a disaster).
Punishment for an offence under Section 188 of the IPC is up to 1 month's imprisonment and a fine of Rs 200, though this can rise to 6 months in jail and a fine of Rs 1000 if the disobedience can cause a danger to human life, health or safety.
If Section 51 of the Disaster Management Act is used instead, the punishment is up to 1 year in jail and a fine - and up to 2 years if the disobedience leads to loss of life.
These punishments cannot of course apply just because the police catches a person, but would require a person to be convicted in a court of law.
Absence of Law
However, as advocate Prasanna S points out, "If the state makes an app like this available for public download and install, and if it collects information as to people's movements, the right to privacy is obviously into play."

Vrinda Bhandari, of-counsel for the Internet Freedom Foundation, explains, "If it (downloading the app) is made mandatory, it will have to be done under the authority of law, and will have to satisfy the necessity and proportionality test for the violation of privacy - this will look at, for instance, what is the data being collected, how long is it stored for, what are the deletion protocols in place."

Any order, whether by the centre or the state government or the DM, will need to state exactly what the legal basis for the order is - failure to do so would mean the order is "demonstrably unconstitutional" as per the Supreme Court's right to privacy judgment, according to Prasanna.
The requirement to establish proportionality and necessity means that limited orders - making it mandatory for those who have tested positive for the coronavirus, for instance - are more likely to be upheld by the courts.

Broad, sweeping orders, where it is not clear if there is a less privacy-restrictive means to achieve the same objective, have a greater chance of being found illegal.

Comments

Contact Form

Name

Email *

Message *

Popular Posts

How To Hack PUBG Mobile on Android || Easily Hack PUBG Game On Android

How To Hack Pubg Mobile On Android in 2020

Fortnite Boogie Down: How to enable 2FA and get free Epic Games

2020 Suzuki Burgman 200 unveiled - India launch unlikelySuzuki's new Burgman 200 churns out 17.7bhp and 18Nm of torque from a 200cc liquid-cooled engine || suzuki burgman 200 price in kolkata

Infinix Hot 9 Pro launch in India-Price-Features-Specifications | Infinix Hot 9 Pro Review

Follow by Email